Skip to content

Webcomic Header

12 Comments

Alyson: scared of getting murdered
Ethan: scared of Phil’s exposition

That’s lived experience trauma, right there.

We all know Phil.

Language nitpick: Brain dead people “experience” trauma differently – just physical trauma, no brain functions involved. (And if you define death differently, I’m worried for you.)

Looking it up, I did use the term semi-incorrectly, but your language nitpick was also incorrect. Apparently “Lived Experience Trauma” is a term used for two related things:

1. The traumatized individual’s response to said trauma. Psychological distress, mental health issues & drug abuse as a result of trauma are all included.

2. The experience of supporting someone with Trauma.

As such, I did use the term incorrectly. I, unfortunately, used it as if the term referred to trauma developed in a RELATIVELY innocent manner (aka, nothing dangerous, physically harmful or intentionally mentally stressful created the trauma), without bothering to look up how the term should actually be used first.

Yes, I made an error – thanks for catching that!

I did not check on if the medical literature used the superfluous term “lived experience” (which all experiences are, unless you are dead), but I found that it had been used in a several research paper’s titles.

I was trying to straight face a term that looked ridiculous. But it has a definition: “In qualitative phenomenological research, lived experience refers to the first-hand involvement or direct experiences and choices of a given person, and the knowledge that they gain from it, as opposed to the knowledge a given person gains from second-hand or mediated source.” However, that still looks ridiculous on its face, since you can’t experience second-hand knowledge (only your first-hand emotional response to being told an anecdote.) The problem seems to be that it derives from philosophy (i.e. phenomenology), not science, so it isn’t about objective facts (as I was discussing) but is a form of meaningless woo. The medical researchers that adopt the term does so on their own risk, some researchers has an infatuation with philosophy.

Leave a Reply

Primary Sidebar